Wireless Music – Part 3: The Results Are In

UPDATE (Aug. 5/08): Logitech doesn’t provide support for this product. By the looks of it, they never did. Eventually mine stopped working. I couldn’t find a simple solution online or through the Logitech website. I don’t recommend this product. It might work for you, but if it doesn’t, then all you have is a piece of junk.

Oops. I kinda forgot to finish my review of the Logitech Wireless Music System I purchased back in March. Here goes — cutting to the chase:

7 out of 10 (7/10). There is room for improvement, and the full retail price is a bit too high, but the product more or less does what I want it to do, so I’m happy.

Hooking up the Logitech Wireless Music System is not difficult. A small transmitter plugs into any USB port; mine’s plugged into the back of my PC. The receiver with a small AC adapter connects to the auxiliary RCA plugs on the back of my iSymphony kitchen stereo. The Logitech software, which took less than a minute to install and configure, is easy to use, but I can tell it was designed by tech-heads — it could have been simplified even more, because most of the time you’re doing one of two things: playing music through your PC speakers or through your remote receiver. That’s it. The sound quality is excellent. No sign of interference. A perfect CD-quality signal every time (or close enough that I can’t tell).7 OUT OF 10

I agree with J-Walk who said, “The only problem is that when it’s transmitting, the local PC sound is muted. In other words, you can listen to the music on the computer or in the remote location — but not in both places at the same time.” Another problem is that my remote control doesn’t work. I can mute the sound and change the volume, but I can’t skip or pause tracks. Returning the product for an exchange requires sending it back and paying for postage, and I can’t be bothered. Skipping tracks would be nice, but it’s not essential.

My main audio player is Winamp, but just about any player will work, including iTunes. Whatever I can play through Winamp (e.g. Whole Wheat Radio or the CBC), I can listen to through the wireless system. Being able to play all the music on my PC through any stereo in my house is convenient too.

The transmission and sound quality are excellent, and it’s easy to use, so I recommend it for those reasons. But I have a feeling this product is a prototype, something Logitech is using to test the marketplace. Hopefully they’ll come out with something that has a more reliable remote control — an on/off switch and an artist/song display on the receiver wouldn’t hurt either. Overall, though, not too bad. (See comments for updates.)

FINAL UPDATE (July 28/08): The damn thing doesn’t work anymore. It was always a bit buggy, but it just doesn’t work. I’m not sure what set it off: the latest XP update, some other software interfering with it — I don’t know and I don’t have the patience to bother with it. I thought it would work on my new Vista PC. It doesn’t. The Logitech Anywhere Music System doesn’t even show up in the sound card options. I enjoyed it while it lasted, but the software and the hardware are poorly designed. I plan to hard-wire all the speakers in my house. It might be more expensive, but at least I know it’ll work.

(See also Wireless Music – Part 1 and Part 2.)

About Phillip

Phillip Cairns is a beekeeper in St. John's, Newfoundland, who writes about beekeeping at mudsongs.org.

3 Replies to “Wireless Music – Part 3: The Results Are In”

  1. Sent mine back at their expense, can’t skip or pause and range very limited,30 feet. New one arrived and still have the same problems. Looking for a better one with features that work.

  2. Norm, what you say doesn’t surprise me. I’ve looked over several online reviews since I wrote this post, and it’s definitely a hit-and-miss product. I didn’t pay much for mine, and didn’t have high expectations. It’s good enough for my purposes, but if I could get a full refund without any hassle, I probably would — and then I’d wait for a better product to come out.

    Several online reviewers report problems. For me, the remote control is unless. But a bigger problem, from what I’ve read online, seems to be the signal cutting out. Coincidentally, the signal on mine began dropping out this past week. I fixed it by plugging the receiver into a dedicated circuit — no extension cords or tool bars. I don’t know why that should make any difference, but it did. Interference from other wireless products seems fairly common too, though so far mine’s working out alright.

    Logitech has already stopped manufacturing the item, probably because there are too many problems with it. I suspect that’s why most of their stock is already available at eBay discount stores. It’s possible to get one that works the way it’s supposed to, but it’s a crap shoot. You’re just as likely to get a piece of junk.

  3. I recently re-installed Windows XP on my machine and consequently had to re-install several applications, including this one. There must be something significantly different about the latest version of XP, because the Logitech Music Anywhere software doesn’t work anymore. I won’t get into, but suffice it to say I’ve tried everything, every possible configuration, and it won’t work. I tried to install it on another PC, and it still doesn’t work. I’ve check online and I’m not the only one having these problems. If you’re lucky to have a machine that happens to accept the software, good for you (apparently Vista can handle it without installing any of the Logitech software). But it seems you’re just as likely to have a machine that will not accept the Logitech software. I’m getting a Vista machine in a few weeks, which I hope solves the problem. If it doesn’t, then that’s it for Logitech’s Music Anywhere. It was always a bit buggy. Too bad. I’m going to miss it. My original 7/10 rating would be much lower now. It’ll be a zero if I can’t get it to work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.